Shenanigans is an Achievement Hunter show that was created on December 19, 2014 with the release of the first episode. This new segment will usually feature the AH staff just pranking and messing with each other. Geoff has stated that it will not be regularly updated. This is likely because the series would eventually become repetitive or expected by the AH staff.
Episode 1 was released on December 19, 2014. In this episode, Geoff, Gavin, Ray, and Michael pulled a prank on Ryan (who was recording on The Patch at the time with Meg and Gus) by changing his Xbox Live gamertag to GiveMeYourMilk, a reference to a previous Minecraft Let's Play. Since Ryan did not have a password set on his Xbox account, the AH guys decided to have some fun with him by secretly changing his gamertag to something stupid. Ray originally came up with the idea to change his gamertag to "HaywoodYaBlowMe", but it was already taken. Ray quickly backed out, while Geoff changed Ryan's gamertag and paid for it. Michael saved Ryan's original gamertag (BM Vagabond) so no one else uses it. The rest of the staff (Jack, Matt, Jeremy and Caleb) thought this was a bad idea and they appeared while they were in the middle of changing it. Geoff then got Gus (also on The Patch) to press the A button on Ryan's Xbox controller to confirm the name change. After the gamertag was changed to GiveMeYourMilk, the AH guys (Michael, Jack, Jeremy, Ray, Matt, Caleb, Trevor, Gavin and Geoff) were having a good laugh. Kerry briefly appeard and said that he had nothing to do with this and begged Ryan to spare him before leaving. The AH guys also discussed what Ryan would feel and how he would react, as well as what they should do when he comes in and finds out. When Ryan suddenly walked into the office and came back 20 minutes later to find out what happened, the AH guys were casually editing and working on AH videos and Let's Plays. Ryan became pissed off and quietly fumed after he found out what happened (despite the AH guys trying to hide the truth). He could tell they were giggling and told the others they are "fucked" (that they are toast, or in deep trouble). He left for just one second, and all hell broke loose. He was also embarrassed that news of his Xbox gamertag news came on the Rooster Teeth reddit (shown on Jeremy's iPhone). Geoff then tried to save himself by saying at first Gavin, and then Gavin and Ray did it. Gavin objected, saying that he only filmed it but Ryan didn't care. Ray also objected, saying that it was only his idea, he just didn't change it. Furthermore, he wanted to change it to "HaywoodYaBlowMe" but it was already taken. Ryan told everyone that he couldn't change it back to BM Vagabond but Geoff says that he can change it back to normal if he wants to because it was saved by Michael so that no one else would use it. Finally, after having a good laugh and admitting that they changed his gamertag behind his back, and that it was just a joke (they were just trying to poke some fun), laughing at Ryan's dismay, Geoff finally told everyone that they had their fun, playtime was over and suggested that they should change Ryan's gamertag back to normal before Ryan "murdered" them since he was clearly pissed off. Ryan's gamertag was later changed back to BM Vagabond.